Kill it or Leave It?

The home we’ve recently moved into has this tree growing in the backyard. Short of decapitating dandelions I’m not much of a gardener but I’m a bit concerned about how close the tree is to the house. It is starting to lean a bit… pushing itself away from the house (not really obvious in the photo).

I would appreciate any suggestions in regards to what we should be doing here. Is the tree okay this close to the house? Should it be cut down? Or maybe just thinned out a bit.

Post to Twitter Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to LinkedIn Post to StumbleUpon

Related Posts

Better comments system?, Backing up your data, The Flood

lazycovernew_all (Small)

Buy Direct

START A CAREER IN GAME DESIGN AWARD WINNING SCIENCE FICTION COMPLETE SERIES


Brent Knowles

Amazon * Twitter * Start a Game Design Career * iTunes * AnthologyBuilder * Stories * Empire Avenue



  • Bev

    Its a  Ceder tree Brent,It is to close  your house… It will wreck the paint on your house,,,,Barry says you could try trimming it,but if it was him he would just cut it down…

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/SocialSoupnz The Girls

    trim it 

    Current score: 0

  • Gordondholden

    I had a very similar situation Brent, and had spiders roosting in it to boot. I ended up trimming away the back half, leaving room between the tree and the house, and shaping what was left into a beautiful woman in a bikini…well, just kidding about the bikini part…lol. Anyway, it looks great! : )

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/StiBeshev S. Beshev

    I would removed it. If is not causing problems now it sure will in the future.

    Current score: 0

  • Gordondholden

    Please don’t give out my email to anyone. Thanks.

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.facebook.com/teri.gidwitz Teri Gidwitz

    Remove it, or if your tree expert tells you it can survive, move it. It’s got to be doing a number on your foundation too.

    Current score: 0

  • sahaguru

    Kill the curiosity which improves your skill. Leave an expression of achieving .

    Current score: 0

  • http://heartofearth.me/ Mark

    That is definitely too close. It is always advisable to trim any branches that contact the house or gutters because when the wind blows physical damage can occur to the structure of the house. Besides this one does not look very attractive to me. Cut it down. First cut about half way down, then maybe a lower cut, and make the final cut at or even a little below the ground. Then you can plant something that you want there. Buy from a reputable nursery in your area and ask questions about what would go good in the spot you want to plant in. Get any other questions you have answered also. Also remember that if the tree is near power lines it might be advisable to get professional help and in some areas it is a legal requirement. Don’t risk electrocution to save a little money!

    Current score: 0

  • waynemansfield

    Chop down for me mate

    Current score: 0

  • Mike R.

    Definitely I’d be cutting this one down, carefully…

    Current score: 0

  • Julie Shatswell

    Take it down. That could be a huge problem in the future esp with the root system. 

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Bev!

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Hah! I’m thinking of trimming it first and then evaluating afterwards. 

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    No worries. 

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Wow, thanks for the detailed advice!

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Definitely will do a trim right away and then evaluate whether to chop the entire thing down.

    Current score: 0

  • http://bajabybus.com/ Baja By Bus

    Get rid!

    Current score: 0

  • Tru2psu

    First, the shrub looks like a Yew – very deep roots.   May be very difficult to remove and replant.

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.ibosocial.com/AjarnDonald Ajarn Donald

    Leave it, Love it, Let it live and it will help out nature and the environment.  :)

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Suzanne-St-Amand/601771189 Suzanne St Amand

    Wait until Christmas and use it as your Christmas tree.

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/IronOakIT Randy L Dyck

    This tree looks a lot like our junipers. We have 2 at each corner of the front of our house, 25 feet tall and  about 2 feet from the foundation. See a couple of pics of our yard on Google+
    These things aren’t getting any taller, and they do well in the dry soil next to the house. Others say the same, see links at bottom. They aren’t like spruce or fir that have huge taproots to put pressure on your foundation.

    https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-Uim_W1US8OU/T8WRKN4vTlI/AAAAAAAAAG8/-IsH65HGdek/w324-h243-n-k/DSCF1165.JPG
    https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-JH0ahor6hXE/T8WRN2gFdLI/AAAAAAAAAHE/e47BkpZdT9M/w324-h243-n-k/DSCF1179.JPG

    Your picture makes it look more like an Eastern Redcedar or a Mountian Redcedar, which are actually Junipers.
    http://treesandshrubs.about.com/od/selection/tp/Juniper-Trees-Shrubs-species.htm
    http://www.homefocus.com/ask-the-expert/archive/landscaping/general/6481/
    http://www.gardeningknowhow.com/trees-shrubs/foundation-plants.htm

    If it is really leaning away from the house, you might want to prune the branches against the house side a bit. Or, just cut the thing down.

    Hope that all helps you make up your mind.

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/CatherineWPhoto Catherine White

    Now that’s a nice Christmas tree :D

    Current score: 0

  • Colin_turnbull

    Chop, chop

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/fsusma Richard Bradford

    Cut it down.

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Yes, my wife doesn’t want it cut down because she wants to decorate it for Christmas.

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Yes, that’s what my wife wants to do :)

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Randy for the details and photos.

    Current score: 0

  • Shawn

    We had a couple smaller versions of your tree/bush when I was kid and they seemed to attract alot of bees and hornets, so we ended up getting rid of them. 
    But Root wise I am not sure how strong they are.

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/pamrumer Pam Rumer

    Since your wife likes the tree, you should try moving it. as that would make her happy (and that is important). I’d read about transplanting evergreens first, or consult an expect. I agree it is too close to the house and depending upon the root system, it could get into pipes, cause cracks in the foundation, etc.

    Current score: 0

  • Dianne

    That tree is nice for beautification and for maintaining fresh air. You can just trim but not cut all…

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Shawn. The yard does seem a bit more bee/hornet heavy than our last.

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    We might do this though the yard isn’t terribly large (i.e., might not be another location for it).

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/BangGowes Syarif S. Arman

    Agree…just trim it…it can be your outdoor christmas tree later…Love tree! @BangGowes:twitter 

    Current score: 0

  • April Elyse Martin

    I say leave it!! 

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.facebook.com/craig.meyer.39 Craig Meyer

    Kill it. Its ugly anyway

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/gregbepper Greg Bepper

    Yep, Randy is right … it’s a Juniper (Type of conifer) .. They don’t ‘trim all that well. No TREE, which it is… should be that close to a house. Roots will find their way into the drainage system looking for water. Remove it and replace with a shrub

    Current score: 0

  • Aytakin

    Leave it

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.facebook.com/andreas.wiedow Andreas Wiedow

    1) This size the tree MUST have roots deep down that keep growing and will finally ruin (the wall of) the house.2) The tree has been planted too close to the house in the first place.

    So remove it. Question is, how ?

    Solutions.

    1) Removing including roots – be careful because of the house.
    2) Dunno if it would keep growing if roots were left underground.
    3) Make something useful out of it: Cut it down to a size that you can use it as a table for BBQ or kids to play. Depends on the diameter of the root.

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/mcwright mcwright

    I’d get rid of it…it’s too close, it will eventually hurt foundation and drainage…plant a hydrangea a bit farther from the wall…

    Current score: 0

  • http://www.stichtingmilieunet.nl/andersbekekenblog Milieunet

    It’s close to the hous, but just leave it.

    Current score: 0

  • Skyhi

    I agree with mcwright it will eventuallt damage the foundation. PS remember when cutting down to cut the trunk under grounf level other wise you will be mowing around it until it rots away.

    Current score: 0

  • Diny

    I would prefer the small one in the container. His big brother is too close to the house and will damage in in the long turn. 

    Current score: 0

  • Robbie

    I think as well that  it’s too near to house foundation, maybe you can just think about moving it 2 meters away…

    Current score: 0

  • http://twitter.com/ChristerOlsson Christer Olsson

    I’d try to trim and thin it, and if does not respond well – remove it.

    Current score: 0

  • geoffrey

    Check the roots out..you could trim it …also make sure it does not wilt.. worse case is… you transfer it

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    :)

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Greg.

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Andreas. Definitely will do something useful with the remains.

    Current score: 0

  • http://blog.brentknowles.com Brent Knowles

    Thanks Skyhi

    Current score: 0